top of page
All Hands In

Unsplash

Why Now is the Time for Clients to Consider Independent Media Agencies

Adam Hopkinson

June 4th 2025

In an industry shaped by consolidation, automation, and procurement pressures, UK advertisers are waking up to the benefits of going boutique. Independent media agencies are not just surviving—they’re thriving. And with a changing media landscape and renewed focus on value, agility, and trust, now is the time for clients to rethink their partnerships.

 

The UK's independent agency sector—represented by organisations like The Alliance of Independent Agencies (formerly the IPA’s Media Futures Group) and PASHN (Practitioners Against Sh*t House Nonsense *)—is growing in confidence and clout. According to recent data from the Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA), advertiser confidence has risen for four consecutive quarters, despite economic headwinds. In Q1 2025, total marketing budgets rose by a net balance of +12.4% (IPA Bellwether Report), with significant investment into channels like online video, gaming, and cinema—spaces where independents tend to play more creatively and nimbly.

 

So, why the shift?

 

First, there’s a growing frustration with the "one-size-fits-none" model of the holding groups. Many advertisers now view network agencies as too big to pivot, with bureaucracy standing in the way of bold decisions. As Head of Media at a major FMCG brand, noted at a recent ISBA summit:


“We needed less PowerPoint and more people who actually understood our business. The indie agency we moved to gave us the senior attention and cultural fit we’d been missing for years.”

 

Second, financial prudence is leading brands to seek out better bang for their buck. Holding companies' cost structures are often bloated by legacy systems, high overheads, and shareholder expectations. Independents, meanwhile, are leaner, meaner, and more aligned with the idea of shared risk and reward. A 2024 Nielsen study found that independent agencies were 23% more likely to be perceived as cost-efficient by clients—without sacrificing effectiveness.

 

Crucially, independents are thriving in sectors where cultural fluency and agility matter. Gaming, fashion, film, DTC retail—these verticals demand constant cultural calibration. That’s where independents win. They’re built to be close to culture, not buried under it. 

 

In early 2025, AG Barr, the company behind the iconic soft drink Irn-Bru, ended its 30-year partnership with their incumbent and appointed London-based independent agency Lucky Generals as its new creative partner. This decision was part of a broader restructuring aimed at expanding the brand's presence, particularly in England. AG Barr's marketing chief, Lucy Henderson, stated:

 

"As our business continues to grow and evolve, we took the decision to look at what a range of agencies could offer us. We've decided to go in a new direction. We're confident Lucky Generals will deliver creative work." 

 

And let’s not forget trust—a commodity in short supply in the advertising ecosystem. The ANA and ISBA reports into media transparency revealed persistent concerns around opaque rebates, inventory quality, and the “black box” nature of programmatic buying. Independent agencies, without the distraction of owned inventory or group trading desks, offer more transparency by design. Clients like knowing that recommendations aren’t coloured by quarterly deals or group margin targets.

 

The Association of Independent Agencies reports a surge in new business wins over the past 18 months, with notable examples including fintechs, challenger FMCGs, and lifestyle brands ditching legacy rosters in favour of boutique players who "get it." 

 

It’s not just emotional—it’s practical. Independents are increasingly forming collectives, pooling thought, sharing insight into tech stacks, and even building international reach without compromising independence. Like others,  PASHN are building a network of like-minded agencies with bespoke media-tech partnerships, insights and offerings, and a central sense of ‘Doing The Right Thing’**

 

The message to clients is simple: the market has moved. Independent agencies are not a risky bet—they’re often the smarter one. In a post-cookie (well, maybe soon), post-COVID, culturally chaotic landscape, brands don’t need more layers. They need sharper thinking, faster decisions, and partners who are in it for more than billings.

 

The independents are open for business. And they’re coming for the big guns—not with bluster, but with better ideas.

 

*It doesn’t stand for that, but I do like it!

**Small podcast plug

bottom of page